Supreme Court to Decide Adelegbe’s Challenge to Arobo’s APC Ticket After Alleged Fair Hearing Breach

By Asaye Bankole

The Supreme Court has scheduled Wednesday, November 18, to hear an appeal filed by Oluwatimehin Emmanuel Adelegbe challenging the emergence of Abdulghani Arobo as the All Progressives Congress (APC) candidate for the Owo/Ose Federal Constituency of Ondo State in the 2027 general elections.

Adelegbe is asking the apex court to overturn the October 9, 2026, judgment of the Abuja Division of the Court of Appeal, which affirmed an earlier decision of the Federal High Court recognising Arobo as the APC’s duly nominated candidate for the House of Representatives seat.

In his appeal, Adelegbe accused the lower courts of denying him a fair opportunity to present crucial evidence establishing his alleged victory in the APC primary election, insisting that the judgment recognising Arobo was delivered without joining him in the proceedings that produced the decision.

The appellant, through his team of lawyers led by Senior Advocate of Nigeria (SAN), Joseph Daudu, filed 18 grounds of appeal, urging the Supreme Court to set aside the Court of Appeal’s judgment and its consequential orders.

He is also seeking an order directing the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) to recognise, publish and maintain his name, profile and nomination particulars as the duly nominated APC candidate for Owo/Ose Federal Constituency.

Adelegbe insists he won APC primary with 13,094 votes

Adelegbe maintained that he emerged victorious at the APC primary election conducted on May 16, 2026, and that the party subsequently submitted his name to INEC as its candidate for the constituency.

To substantiate his claim, he sought to introduce additional documentary evidence before the Court of Appeal, including the APC’s official candidate forwarding letter dated June 26, 2026, his Form EC9 affidavit, an INEC Candidate Nomination Portal submission receipt dated July 11, 2026, and a certified true copy of the APC Election Committee’s official result sheet.

According to the appellant, the result sheet indicated that he polled 13,094 votes in the primary election.

However, he faulted the Court of Appeal for refusing his application to tender the documents as fresh evidence, arguing that the materials were essential to establishing his claim to the party’s ticket.

In the first ground of appeal, Adelegbe contended that the appellate court occasioned a miscarriage of justice by refusing his application brought pursuant to Order 4 Rule 2 of the Court of Appeal Rules 2021.

He argued that the provision empowers the appellate court to receive additional evidence, particularly where a party was prevented from presenting such evidence at the trial court through circumstances beyond his control.

‘Judgment was delivered behind my back’

A major issue raised in Adelegbe’s appeal is his allegation that Arobo deliberately excluded him from the proceedings at the Federal High Court, thereby denying him the opportunity to defend his interest in the disputed APC ticket.

The appellant maintained that he was never served with court processes relating to the suit instituted by Arobo and only became aware of the proceedings after the trial court had delivered its judgment on August 5, 2026.

According to Adelegbe, his exclusion from the proceedings deprived him of the opportunity to present documentary evidence showing that he was the person declared winner of the APC primary election.

He further argued that the Court of Appeal wrongly applied the doctrine of estoppel by ‘standing by’ against him.

The doctrine generally prevents a person who knowingly allows another individual to litigate an issue affecting their interest without participating from subsequently challenging the outcome.

However, Adelegbe contended that the principle could not apply to his situation because he had no actual or constructive knowledge of the suit before judgment was delivered.

He maintained that the doctrine requires clear evidence that the affected person knew about the proceedings, had a direct interest in the subject matter and consciously decided not to participate.

Consequently, he argued that it was legally wrong for the appellate court to hold that he was bound by the outcome of proceedings of which he had no knowledge.

Adelegbe challenges Arobo’s decision to approach Federal High Court

The appellant also faulted the Court of Appeal for holding that Arobo was justified in approaching the Federal High Court without exhausting the APC’s internal dispute-resolution mechanism.

He argued that Arobo ought to have pursued the party’s internal appeal process through its National Working Committee (NWC) before instituting the action at the trial court.

Adelegbe further challenged the decision of the appellate court affirming the use of an originating summons to commence the suit, despite what he described as serious and conflicting factual allegations surrounding the disputed primary election.

He also argued that the proceedings violated his constitutional right to fair hearing under Section 36(1) of the 1999 Constitution, as amended, because he was not joined as an indispensable party whose interest was directly affected by the case.

How the dispute reached the Supreme Court

The legal battle originated from a suit filed by Arobo at the Federal High Court in Abuja, where Justice Peter Lifu, on August 5, 2026, delivered judgment recognising him as the APC candidate for Owo/Ose Federal Constituency.

Dissatisfied with the decision, Adelegbe’s legal battle continued at the Abuja Division of the Court of Appeal.

However, the appellate court, in its October 9 judgment in appeal number CA/ABJ/CV/1235/2026, affirmed the Federal High Court’s decision.

Adelegbe has now approached the Supreme Court, seeking to reverse both decisions and restore his claim to the APC ticket.

The respondents in the appeal are Arobo, the APC and the Independent National Electoral Commission.

With the Supreme Court fixing Wednesday, November 18, for the hearing, the proceedings are expected to be a significant development in the dispute over the APC’s representation in Owo/Ose Federal Constituency ahead of the 2027 general elections.

The apex court’s eventual determination will be crucial to resolving the competing claims over the party’s ticket.

Spread the love

COMMENTS